Current Issues

The Uncatechized Baptized Member  

 by Forum Team Member  Rick Goodwin

The various rites for candidates (baptized but uncatechized Roman Catholics or members of another Christian community) provided in the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults in the United States and Canada are beginning to receive greater attention after ten years of pastoral experience.  How well have they worked?  Have they been properly implemented?  A related question is the inclusion of candidates in the dismissal rite, whether in company with catechumens or in their own group. Team member Rick Goodwin offers some initial insights into the values involved.

What is a catechumenate director or, for that matter, the parish to do in relation to catechumens, candidates, and the dismissal rite?  With catechumens, the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults is quite clear and precise.  The journey of faith is outlined and precisely mapped out for the person who is coming from no faith to faith.  The true messiness in the catechumenate is working with candidates who are already baptized, perhaps even confirmed, but are uncatechized.  It is important to point out that these brief reflections refer only to candidates who are uncatechized, not catechized.  As for the latter cases, these candidates do not follow the guidelines of the catechumenate (see, for example, the U.S. edition of the Rite, ANational Statutes for the Catechumenate@, no. 31).

I refer to an uncatechized adult as anyone who has reached catechetical age, but has received little or no faith formation.  In other words the person may know information and even some Catholic practices, but is not in a living relationship with the Church.

How do we live out the integrity of the Rite when A>those who have already been baptized in another Church or ecclesial community should not be treated as catechumens or so designated@ (U.S. National Statutes, no. 30)? Are candidates dismissed or not?  The A>sorting of fish= should depend on the extent to which the baptized person has led a Christian life within a community of faith and been appropriately catechized to deepen his or her inner adherence to the Church@ (U.S. NS, no. 30). The Rite suggests that the whole parish , not just the initiation team, must welcome candidates to complete their initiation or welcome those to full communion (see U.S. NS, no. 9).   This means that the doctrinal and sprirtual journey of each uncatechized candidate is individually constructed to meet the needs of the member.  We can no longer indiscriminately place candidates with catechumens for lack of community support.  This is not a good pastoral decision or pastoral practice.

A critical look at the U.S. edition of the Rite indicates that no direction is given for candidates to join the catechumens in the dismissal, or, alternatively, to be sent forth as a group of their own. In its purest form, the dismissal rite exists for catechumens. The Rite clearly states Atheir status (candidates) differs from that of catechumens, since by baptism they have already become members of the Church and children of God@ (U.S. edition, para. 400). Nonetheless, the Rite directs that they may take part in some ritual elements of the catechumenal formation, either parallel to the formation being experienced by the catechumens or together with them (see, for example, U.S. edition paras. 402, 406, 407, 478, and U.S. NS nos. 25, 30, 31). Further, the Canadian edition of the Rite makes provision for dismissal of the candidates for reception following the intercessory prayer for the candidates in the Rite of Welcoming (see Canadian edition paragraphs 467-487). In either case, the Rite  assumes careful discernment. For good pastoral reason, then, it may be appropriate to invite the uncatechized candidates to go forth from the assembly with their catechist after the homily.

 The priority of baptism must emphatically be considered before the community includes candidates in the dismissal rite, whether or not this is done in conjunction with the dismissal of catechumens.  This takes careful discernment with the candidate.  Only after recognizing the baptismal status of the individual will we as a community of faith grow to appreciate more fully our own baptismal commitment.

 An excellent resource for further study of this and related issues is One at the Table: The Reception of Baptized Christians, ed. Ronald A. Oakham, O.Carm. (available through Forum=s Book Service).

 Rick Goodwin


[ Home ] [ About Us ] [ Calendar ] [ Current Issues ]
[ Special Engagements ] [ Book Service ] [ Contact Us ]